Bicycle TutorBicycle Tutor

Show off your bike!

Post Reply 

Choosing the right rear derailleur replacement

Related video tutorials:
How to Adjust Your Front Derailleur How to Adjust Your Front Derailleur
* Now with 3D interactive instructions
Author Message
mykalgrows Offline
New Member

Boulder, Colorado
Posts: 1
Joined: May 2010
Post: #1
Choosing the right rear derailleur replacement
I busted my rear derailleur (shimano sora) on my specialized sirrus. This is a good-enough-reason to upgrade both my shifters and my RD.

It appears that it's difficult to find a basic, straight-forward explanation of what to look for & things to consider when you're looking for a replacement. I've been slowly upgrading my bike as things wear down, and I'd like either a shimano LX or XT rear derailleur, but I'm not sure if it would work with my cassette/chainrings. Here's the info about my bike from the manufacturer:

cassette: HG-50, 8 speed, 12x25T
chainring: 48s/38s/28s

and from Sheldon Brown, I know you subtract 12 from 25 (13), and 28 from 48 (20), and add the results (33). And that a derailleur that lists 33 or more as its total capacity should work.

But that doesn't say much to me. Brown's info is from an old article too, so does this still apply? What about short cage/long cage? etc.

Someone on another thread here had said that as long as it's shimano, and you get the right kind (gs or sgs), you'll be fine. That seems too simple.

-Mike
May 27, 2010 01:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JonB Offline
Senior Member

Wales, UK
Posts: 232
Joined: Nov 2008
Post: #2
RE: Choosing the right rear derailleur replacement
Both the LX and XT should work, and I think you can get away with short cage (but I'm not sure about super-short). The advantage of the short cage is that if you run it off-road it makes it much harder to catch it on rocks, stumps etc. and bend it. XT as I recall can be used on 9-spd, so will be fine.
May 28, 2010 06:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DaveM Offline
Veteran Member


Posts: 1,398
Joined: Aug 2008
Post: #3
RE: Choosing the right rear derailleur replacement
I believe any shimano rear derailleur will work, except "rapid rise" which springs the alternate direction. Generally with a triple in the front, you can't use short cage. "GS" are mid-cage and have a max of 33 teeth in the back so it would work. SGS can handle up to 42 in the back. Shorter cages generally have slightly crisper shifting and shave a tiny bit of weight, but it really won't make a big difference.

Changing shifters could be a bigger issue. I think Sora is the highest level 8 speed. If you go to a 9 or 10 speed shifter you at least have to change cassettes and I'm not sure if you get in to an issue with the wheel or not.
May 28, 2010 10:16 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
cyclerUK Offline
Veteran Member


Posts: 753
Joined: Jan 2009
Post: #4
RE: Choosing the right rear derailleur replacement
Does your bike have "Sora" shifters. The "Sirrus" is shown to have flat bars so the shifters won't be Sora.

You say the rear sprockets are 12-25T. Then that is why you have a Sora RD. Obviously XT or LX are MTB mech's and are designed to be used with a MTB cassette ranges. ie: 11-28 upto 11-34.
Unless you are going to go much bigger than the 25T at the back then you are better off sticking with a road RD. XT/Lx will work but not as sweatly.
The reason for the long cage rear derailleurs is for triple front rings. Depending on the sizes will decide whether you need a mid or long cage version. Definitely not short cage as they are designed for double chainsets only.

Just to add - Front derailleurs are different. You can't swap between road and MTB front deraiileurs as they have a different pull.
Road = 13mm per click of changer.
MTB = 19mm per click.

Ride hard or ride home alone!
May 28, 2010 12:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
j87soccer Offline
New Member


Posts: 1
Joined: Jun 2012
Post: #5
RE: Choosing the right rear derailleur replacement
I need to find a rear derailleur for my mongoose sabre 21 speed bike but dont know what i need or anything thanks for your help.
Jun 8, 2012 11:41 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
trevgbb Offline
Senior Member

West Midlands UK
Posts: 416
Joined: Apr 2010
Post: #6
RE: Choosing the right rear derailleur replacement
http://cycle.shimano-eu.com/
http://bike.shimano.com/
search for component specs and compatibilty issues, see tech docs.
Jun 8, 2012 11:55 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread: Author Replies: Views: Last Post
  Rear Shifting Problems! cricket0140 5 245 Oct 19, 2014 06:08 AM
Last Post: painkiller
  Front derailleur/chainring gap py3gemini 2 261 Oct 13, 2014 09:57 AM
Last Post: cny-man
  Buying a new rear derailleur. la569 6 986 Sep 30, 2014 04:51 AM
Last Post: la569
  Problems with front derailleur. neil180 1 832 Sep 9, 2014 03:13 PM
Last Post: cny-man
  Front Derailleur problem/whole shifting system benonidoni1 9 898 Sep 7, 2014 07:19 PM
Last Post: cny-man
  Schwinn Continental Derailleur Replacements FrenchLop 6 816 Sep 1, 2014 02:00 PM
Last Post: cny-man
  I can only use the highest 5 gears on my 8spd rear cog bianchi29er 21 10,073 Sep 1, 2014 02:35 AM
Last Post: wikey
  Rear derailer refuses to travel from top to low gear bike adventurers 6 863 Aug 28, 2014 11:07 AM
Last Post: bike adventurers
  13/23 to 14/28 rear derailleur question Jamin 6 693 Aug 28, 2014 01:51 AM
Last Post: Jamin
  Shimano shifter replacement question Cormitt 3 849 Aug 26, 2014 09:06 AM
Last Post: nfmisso

Forum Jump:


RSS Forum RSS Feeds / Powered by MyBB

ISSN 1918-3445 © Copyright 2007-2010 Bicycle Tutor / Privacy Policy

feed